HomeMusicPandora Got Sued Over Playlist Technology, But a Judge Now

Pandora Got Sued Over Playlist Technology, But a Judge Now

A federal judge says Pandora won’t have to face a patent lawsuit that the streamer called a “shakedown,” ruling that the supposedly proprietary playlist technology was so basic that it shouldn’t have been patented in the first place.

A company called Bluebonnet accused Pandora of infringing patents that allow users to generate playlists based on their preferences. But in a decision handed down Wednesday, Judge Vince Chhabria ruled that that was merely an “abstract idea” that couldn’t be locked up under patent law.

“These claims may capture the core of a good business idea,” the judge wrote. “But they are directed to an abstract idea and lack an inventive concept—and are therefore invalid.”

When boiled down, the judge said Bluebonnet’s system was really just the idea of “customizing a product according to a customer’s likes and dislikes” – something he said was hardly a novel concept: “Tailoring products to fit taste is a long-prevalent practice and one of the building blocks of human ingenuity that cannot itself be patented.”

In a statement to Billboard, a spokesman for Pandora said the company was “pleased” with the ruling: “As this case demonstrates, Pandora will not fall victim to the shakedown tactics of nonpracticing entities and will vigorously defend itself against baseless claims.”

Attorneys for Bluebonnet did not immediately return requests for comment on the decision.

Bluebonnet sued Pandora in 2020, claiming the internet radio giant had ripped off three different patents that the firm had purchased from a defunct tech startup called Friskit Inc. The patents at issue in the case cover a “playback interface” that streams media from a server to a device, a “rating system” that takes and stores user feedback, and a tool that “automatically and dynamically” generates a playlist based on the ratings.

But in Wednesday’s decision, Judge Chhabria said the patents describe broad ideas, not a “particular technological improvement” that would help to generate better playlists. He cited the fact that the original inventor “acknowledged that it did not invent streaming media, playlists or media players,” as well as a seminal Supreme Court ruling that says merely adding computer technology does not make an abstract idea patentable.

“These are functional and generic computer subsystems that merely mark out the steps of implementing the abstract idea,” the judge wrote. “The term ‘playlist generator,’ for example, is just a placeholder for whatever computer software or hardware performs that step.”

Read The Full Article Here

Must Read

spot_img
Nickelodeon Star Lindsay Felton Is Battling Breast Cancer
After Reports That He Previously Dated Noah Cyrus, Tish Cyrus’
The Craziest Backyard! These People
Bethenny Frankel Responded To Criticism After Posting Her 13-Year-Old Daughter
Hiding From The Alien! Scene
‘Ahsoka’: Who Is the Sith Inquisitor?
BUTCHER’S CROSSING Trailer (NEW 2023)
The enduring joy of Dick Cavett’s Old Hollywood interviews
‘Leverage’ Star Gina Bellman Inspired to Go Public With Cancer
‘Uncoupled’ Stars React to Show’s Second Cancellation
‘When Calls the Heart’ Star Kevin McGarry Thinks Elizabeth &
Law & Order SVU Season 25 Episode 8 Featured a
Rocky Kramer’s Rock & Roll Tuesdays Presents “Rock VS Punk” On Tuesday January 23rd, 2024, 7 PM PT on Twitch
Rocky Kramer’s Rock & Roll Tuesdays Presents “Black & Blue” On Tuesday November 28th, 2023, 7 PM PT On Twitch
Rocky Kramer’s Rock & Roll Tuesdays Presents “Sharp Dressed Man” On Tuesday November 14th, 2023, 7 PM PT on Twitch
Baker Grace’s New Single “Painkiller” Available Friday, November 3rd, 2023 Worldwide
Simonetta Lein – Making A Positive Impact On The World
Rising MMA Sensation Bear Fiorda and UFC Veteran Jorge Masvidal Unite at L.A. Fashion Week, Bridging Past and Future
PSA: The M&S Boots That Fooled Everyone Into Thinking They’re
Jodie Turner-Smith Shuts Down the Red Carpet in Nothing but
Linda Blair Took on an Important Role in ‘The Exorcist:
DEAR DAVID Starring Augustus Prew, Andrea Bang, Rene Escobar Jr
THE HAUNTING LODGE From the creators of The House in
The Heartbreaking Case of Ingrid Lyne [Watch]
Olamide, Asake
Imagine Dragons
BNXN fka Buju, Kizz Daniel & Seyi Vibez
Ed Sheeran